Skip to main content

Best Italian Restaurant in Rochester

Satisfy Your Cravings at Paninoteca

Featured

View menu

Dive into the Most-Loved Creations

Get our free app

Get promotions, track orders, and reorder favorites in seconds.

Download on the App StoreGet it on Google Play
Park Avenue Paninoteca app preview
Savor the Fusion

Savor the Fusion

Dive into a culinary adventure where American flair meets Italian finesse. Our menu boasts a delightful array of main dishes, with a spotlight on authentic Italian specialties. From hearty pasta to savory paninis, every bite is a journey to the heart of flavors.
Effortless Enjoyment

Effortless Enjoyment

We get it – life's hustle is real! That's why we've made indulging in our scrumptious offerings a breeze. With our hassle-free delivery and pickup services, you can enjoy your favorite dishes without breaking a sweat. Feeling the urge to share the joy? Let our catering services elevate your next gathering with a touch of culinary excellence.
Your Table, Your Time

Your Table, Your Time

At Park Avenue Paninoteca, we believe in simplicity and joy. Whether you're a local seeking a laid-back dining experience or a visitor craving the essence of American-Italian fusion, our doors are wide open for you. Drop by and dine in, or order online for a cozy night at home – the choice is yours.

Order From Our Website

Order directly from our website to save money in fees, get faster service, earn free food via our rewards program, and support local business.
Order Now!
Your Gateway to American-Italian Delights

Your Gateway to American-Italian Delights

Welcome to Park Avenue Paninoteca, your neighborhood hub for a delicious rendezvous with American-Italian cuisine. Conveniently located at 230 Monroe Ave, Rochester, NY 14607, we bring you a seamless blend of flavors, warmth, and ease. Take a sneak peek into what makes us your go-to spot.

We got the panini and pasta and it was gas. Absolute gas plus. The flavors were on point, everything tasted super fresh and authentic. It even reminded my friend of his time in Italy, it was that gas. The place was clean, affordable, and had a nice chill vibe. Definitely coming back again. If you’re in the area and craving real Italian style food, this spot’s a must.

Mustafa A.

Came here for lunch with my brother. Absolutely excellent! The food reminded me of my time in Italy, high quality ingredients and just the perfect amount of flavor. Rigatoni was perfectly al dente, panini was soft and crunchy at the same time. The gentleman behind the counter was very nice. Outstanding service, delicious food, affordable prices, what more can you ask? We will definitely be back!

The D.

I just ordered lunch here for the first time this afternoon, and it was an incredible experience! From the friendly phone call to the smooth pick-up, the customer service was top-notch. The food was fresh and delicious— the gnocchi and Vincenzo Panini were absolutely amazing, a total chef’s kiss! And don't even get me started on the tiramisu and peanut butter bar dessert... so good! I highly recommend this place and can’t wait to come back and dine in person!

Vanessa

My husband hosted my surprise 50th birthday party here and it couldn’t have been more perfect! The staff went above and beyond. They were very attentive, organized and friendly to all.The food was outstanding as always! This is my favorite restaurant in Rochester and i can’t recommend Paninoteca enough to others. A huge thank you to the staff for making the evening unforgettable. Can’t wait to go back again

Andrea G.

I can't say enough about Park Ave Paninoteca! This place is a true gem! The paninis are out of this world, and their Italian mac & cheese is becoming legendary. The fantastic service makes every interaction a pleasure. Whether it's a quick lunch or catering for my entire office, they are the best!!

Rita M.

After eating here for years, I can say that the quality is consistently fantastic, service is FAST and price won't break the bank. I appreciate Paninoteca for being here and being one of my favorite staples. Highly recommend the Chicken Parm panini.

MJ

Park Avenue Paninoteca Rewards

Join our rewards program to earn points, get free items, and stay up to date with us.
Join Park Avenue Paninoteca Rewards

Featuring

Catering

Healthy Options

Easy Parking

Vegan Options

Frequently Asked Questions

What are your most popular dishes?

Park Avenue Paninoteca is known for sandwich-focused Italian food. Our most popular dishes include:

  • The Vincenzo Panini: Chicken cutlet comes with spicy sopressata, red onion, roasted red peppers, arugula, provolone cheese, and light mayo.
  • Chicken Parm Panini: A hand-breaded chicken cutlet dipped in homemade sauce with mozzarella and pecorino Romano cheese.
  • Meatball Panini: Homemade meatballs and sauce with mozzarella and pecorino Romano cheese.
  • Traditional Arancini: A rice ball filled with ground beef, peas, and mozzarella cheese, served with homemade signature sauce on the side.
  • Rigatoni Soprano: Rigatoni in homemade sauce with a touch of cream, crushed meatball, and mozzarella and pecorino Romano cheeses.
  • Cubano: Slow-roasted house pork with ham, Swiss cheese, dill pickles, and mustard.

Check out our full menu.

What are you known for?

We are known for Caponata, Soup, Arancini, Meatballs, Catering, Quesadillas, Pie, Grilled Chicken, Gnocchi, Pasta, Sandwiches, Chocolate Chip Cookie, Panini, Fries, Cheesecake, Fast Food, Tiramisu, French Fries, German Potato Salad, Lasagna, Pasta Salad, Deli Sandwiches, Caprese, Caesar Salad, Dessert, Bar Food, Vegetarian Food, Salads, and Cannoli

What meals do you serve?

We serve Lunch and Dinner

Do you offer delivery & takeout?

Yes, we offer Takeout and Delivery

Do you offer catering?

Yes! Park Avenue Paninoteca offers catering for parties, office lunches, family gatherings, and other events. Our catering menu features our Italian food favorites, available for pickup or delivery.

Visit our catering page for more information.

What payment methods do you accept?

When you order online, we accept credit cards (Mastercard, Visa, American Express, Discover), Apple Pay, and Google Pay.

Services & amenities

Is there parking nearby? Yes, there is parking nearby.

Is your restaurant wheelchair accessible? Yes, our restaurant is wheelchair accessible.

Do you have Wi-Fi? Yes, we have Wi-Fi.

Can you accommodate large groups? Yes, we can accommodate large groups.

What areas do you serve?

We serve the following areas: Rochester, Brighton, Arnett, Otis, Central Business District, Southwedge, Neighborhood Of The Arts, Westfall, Highland Park, Irondequoit, Park Meigs, S. Marketview Heights, Crittenden, Park Central, Conea, N. Marketview Heights, Plymouth-exchange, Beechwood, Ridgeland, and Wadsworth Square.

Our location

Map showing the location of Park Avenue Paninoteca on 230 Monroe Ave in Rochester
Park Avenue Paninoteca

Rochester, NY

Loading today's hours...
Order online
Order with AppOrder online